I love Benefit products and when I saw the cleanser I was… perplexed. As far as I can tell, this is just like the cleanser that they just took off the market – their Not onMy Pillow cleanser. It worked the same way. Furthermore, I tried both cleansers and both work very well. I liked the bottle of the old cleanser but that’s a minor complaint and because I don’t have the ingredient listing of the old cleanser, I can’t tell you whether the two are actually the same formulations.
But they work the same way, so if you’re looking for a new makeup remover, you may want to try this one.