Things I finished that I won’t replace: Sukin Jelly Exfoliator. This was actually gentle and didn’t have very much grit, but it also wasn’t great at cleaning and just didn’t do anything.
Alumier Retinol 1.0. This was a strong retinol in a very drying, gritty base. Pass on this just because of the texture.
Kat Von D Tattoo Liner. I never reached for this – it was long-lasting and went on ok, but I don’t think the price is justified. There are perfectly good liquid eyeliners at the drugstore.