I love it when drugstore products have some luxury with them too and that’s definitely the came with these Annabelle Cosmetics retractable eyeliners; they have sharpeners on the end so that you can achieve a precise line if you’re using them to line your lids. Sometimes I find that it’s easier to start with pencil eyeliner and then go to a liquid on top. The pencil allows you to correct the shape, and the liquid is long-lasting.
I have them in Granite (the dark grey), Rose Gold, and Plum. Of course, I’m gravitating towards the plum, but they are all smudge-able so you can use them as eyeliner or as shadow.
